Introduction: Indianapolis’s Pizza Paradise
Indianapolis, a city celebrated for its racing heritage and burgeoning cultural scene, also boasts a surprisingly robust and delicious pizza landscape. From cozy neighborhood joints slinging classic pies to innovative kitchens pushing the boundaries of pizza artistry, the Circle City offers a slice for every palate. But with so many tempting options, how do you navigate this cheesy, saucy maze to find the absolute best pizza in Indianapolis? That’s where this guide comes in. We’ve embarked on a delicious quest to uncover the top pizzerias in Indianapolis, highlighting the unique flavors, textures, and atmospheres that make each one special. Whether you’re a die-hard New York-style devotee, a Neapolitan purist, or an adventurous eater eager to sample the latest culinary creations, prepare to discover your new favorite Indianapolis pizza spot. Indianapolis boasts a diverse and delicious pizza scene, with options for every preference, and this guide highlights the best.
What Makes a Great Indianapolis Pizza?
Before we dive into the specifics, let’s consider what truly defines “good pizza.” While personal preferences certainly play a role, certain fundamental elements consistently contribute to a truly exceptional pizza experience. First and foremost is the crust. Is it thin and crispy, foldable and chewy, or thick and airy? The crust serves as the foundation, providing texture and flavor that complements the toppings. The sauce is another critical component. Is it made from fresh tomatoes, subtly sweet, or tangy and robust? The sauce should be balanced and never overpowering. Next, the cheese. Quality matters here – a generous layer of creamy, melty mozzarella can elevate a pizza from good to great. Finally, the toppings. Fresh, high-quality ingredients are essential, and creative combinations can add depth and complexity to the pizza. Of course, the overall experience matters too. The atmosphere, service, and value all contribute to whether a pizzeria becomes a beloved local haunt or simply another forgettable meal. So consider this a guide to getting some of the best pizza in Indianapolis.
The Contenders: Indianapolis’s Top Pizza Havens
Let’s journey through some of the top pizza destinations in Indianapolis. I’ve hand-selected a few favorites, that should give you a great starting point.
Napolese: A Neapolitan Dream
Located in both the Meridian-Kessler and CityWay neighborhoods, Napolese is a true gem for those seeking authentic Neapolitan pizza in Indianapolis. Step inside and you’ll be greeted by the mesmerizing sight of a wood-fired oven, the heart of their pizza-making process. They champion the use of simple, high-quality ingredients, sourcing local produce whenever possible. The dough, carefully crafted and allowed to ferment for optimal flavor, is stretched by hand and cooked in a blistering hot oven for just a minute or two, resulting in a perfectly charred and blistered crust. Their classic Margherita pizza is a must-try, featuring San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil. The simplicity allows the quality of the ingredients to shine through. If you’re feeling more adventurous, try the Carciofi, topped with artichokes, olives, and garlic. The atmosphere is upscale yet relaxed, making it perfect for a special occasion or a casual night out. You can find them at multiple locations and on social media. Napolese really is the perfect place for a taste of authentic Naples. The price range is moderate.
Brozinni Pizzeria: A New York Slice of Indianapolis
For a taste of classic New York-style pizza in Indianapolis, look no further than Brozinni Pizzeria. With multiple locations throughout the city, Brozinni’s offers a taste of the Big Apple without leaving the Midwest. Their pizzas are known for their thin, foldable crust, tangy tomato sauce, and generous toppings. A standout choice is the “Godfather,” a hearty pizza piled high with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Each pizza is made to order and the toppings are always fresh. The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or a pizza night with the kids. Brozinni’s has become something of an Indianapolis institution. So grab a slice from a location near you. The price is fair and worth it.
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza: A Taste of Something Different
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza, with locations in Irvington, Greenwood, and Castleton, is the place to go when you’re craving something a little different. Jockamo’s is known for its eclectic menu and creative toppings, offering a welcome departure from the traditional pizza scene. This restaurant offers many options for people that want to try something a bit off the beaten path. They are also family-owned and community-focused. One of their most popular pizzas is the “BBQ Chicken,” featuring barbecue sauce, grilled chicken, red onions, and cilantro. Another favorite is the “Mediterranean,” topped with artichoke hearts, feta cheese, olives, and roasted red peppers. Jockamo’s also offers a wide selection of craft beers and cocktails, making it a great place to unwind after a long day. The atmosphere is lively and fun, with quirky décor and friendly staff. Their service is attentive and you will never leave hungry. Plan a visit to see what sets them apart. The price range is moderate.
King Dough: Artistry on a Plate
King Dough, located in the Holy Rosary neighborhood, is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a culinary destination. They believe that pizza is art, not just food and this really comes out in the pizza. Their pizzas are crafted with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and creative flavor combinations. The dough is made in-house daily, and the toppings are sourced from local farms whenever possible. A must-try is the “Meatball Pie,” featuring homemade meatballs, ricotta cheese, and a rich tomato sauce. Another standout is the “Prosciutto & Fig,” topped with prosciutto, fig jam, goat cheese, and balsamic glaze. King Dough also offers a carefully curated selection of wines and beers to complement your pizza. The atmosphere is modern and stylish, with a vibrant energy that makes it a perfect spot for a date night or a gathering with friends. Expect to wait for a table, but the pizza is absolutely worth the wait. It’s not just pizza; it’s an experience. The price range is a bit higher, but the quality justifies the cost. Check out their website or social media for more information.
Bazbeaux Pizza: Indianapolis Staple
Bazbeaux Pizza is a long-standing Indianapolis favorite, with multiple locations across the city. They have been serving up delicious pizza since the mid-1980s. They are known for their thin-crust pizzas, unique topping combinations, and casual, inviting atmosphere. Whether you are on the northside or downtown, you can find a Bazbeaux. A popular option is the “Quatro Formaggio”, a pizza topped with a variety of cheeses like Mozzarella, provolone, fontina, and asiago. Another option is the “Pesto Primavera” with pesto sauce, a light primavera mix, and plenty of cheese. The atmosphere is family friendly and the service is always prompt. The price is right too!
Puccini’s Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta: An Easy Classic
Puccini’s Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta is a local chain that has been serving Indianapolis and surrounding areas for many years. Known for consistent quality and a family-friendly atmosphere, Puccini’s provides an extensive menu that is sure to have something for everyone. Offering a range of classic and inventive pizzas, pastas, salads, and sandwiches, it’s a great place for a casual meal or family gathering. Their pizza offerings are diverse, including thin crust and Sicilian style, allowing for a customized experience. The “Big Kahuna” is an offering that is topped with bacon, pineapple, ham, and green onion, providing a balance of sweet and savory flavors. For those who like a bit of spice, the “Hot Mama” features a spicy ranch sauce, chicken, bacon, and jalapenos. You can find them on social media or at a location near you!
Beyond the Pizza: Completing the Experience
While the pizza itself is the star of the show, many of these pizzerias offer additional delights to enhance your dining experience. Look for appetizers like garlic knots, bruschetta, or salads to start your meal. Many establishments boast impressive craft beer selections, allowing you to pair your pizza with the perfect brew. And don’t forget dessert! From classic cannoli to decadent chocolate cake, a sweet treat is the perfect way to end your pizza adventure. Many of the establishments also offer happy hour options so make sure to find the best time to visit!
Tips for the Indianapolis Pizza Enthusiast
Don’t be afraid to venture beyond your comfort zone. Indianapolis’ pizza scene is constantly evolving, with new restaurants and innovative creations popping up all the time. Try a new style, sample an unusual topping, or explore a different neighborhood. Talk to locals, read reviews, and ask for recommendations. And most importantly, be open to trying new things. Every pizzeria has its own unique personality and approach, and you never know what hidden gems you might discover. Also, always remember to support local businesses. These restaurants contribute to the vibrancy of our community, and your patronage helps them thrive.
Conclusion: A City of Slices
Indianapolis’ pizza scene is a reflection of the city itself: diverse, welcoming, and full of surprises. From traditional Neapolitan pies to innovative culinary creations, there’s a pizza for every taste and occasion. So, embark on your own pizza journey through Indianapolis. Explore new neighborhoods, try different styles, and discover the hidden gems that make this city a true pizza paradise. It’s time to grab a slice and discover your new favorite pizza spot in Indianapolis!
