The allure of a perfectly crafted pizza is undeniable. Its comforting aroma, the satisfying crunch of the crust, and the symphony of flavors dancing on the palate—it’s a culinary experience enjoyed the world over. And in St. John’s, Newfoundland and Labrador, this universal language of comfort food is spoken with a distinct local accent. The oldest city in North America, St. John’s, with its iconic jellybean row houses clinging to rugged hillsides overlooking the Atlantic, boasts a surprisingly vibrant and diverse food scene. While Newfoundland is renowned for its seafood and traditional fare, a growing number of establishments are dedicated to crafting exceptional pizza. From wood-fired ovens producing Neapolitan masterpieces to innovative kitchens experimenting with locally sourced ingredients, the pizza St. John’s NL scene is thriving.
This article delves into the heart of that scene, exploring some of the best places to find your perfect slice. We’ll journey from bustling downtown eateries to cozy neighbourhood gems, highlighting the unique offerings, distinct atmospheres, and passionate people behind the delicious pizza in St. John’s. Prepare to discover a taste of Italy infused with Newfoundland charm, a testament to the city’s evolving culinary landscape and its dedication to delivering unforgettable flavors.
A Taste of History: How Pizza Found Its Way to the Rock
The story of pizza in St. John’s mirrors its global journey, arriving as part of the wider culinary expansion of Italian-American cuisine. In the mid-twentieth century, as North America embraced the simple pleasures of a well-made pie, pizza parlors began to sprout across the continent, and eventually reached Newfoundland’s shores. Initially, the options were limited to chain restaurants and basic iterations, providing a familiar and affordable meal. But over time, as culinary awareness grew and more diverse tastes took hold, the pizza scene evolved. Local entrepreneurs and chefs, inspired by both traditional techniques and contemporary trends, began to craft their own unique takes on this beloved dish.
This evolution has led to the vibrant panorama of choices we see today. From the classic thin-crusts adorned with simple, high-quality ingredients, reminiscent of the pizzerias of Naples, to the thick, hearty pies laden with toppings and oozing with cheese, there’s a slice for every palate in St. John’s. What sets the pizza St. John’s NL experience apart is the growing emphasis on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, a reflection of Newfoundland’s strong connection to its land and sea. While not every pizzeria exclusively uses local goods, an increasing number are committed to incorporating them, resulting in pizzas that are both familiar and uniquely Newfoundland.
The Pizzeria: A Downtown Delight
Nestled on Water Street, in the heart of downtown, The Pizzeria exudes a rustic charm. Its exposed brick walls, warm lighting, and the aroma of wood-fired dough create a cozy and inviting atmosphere. They specialize in Neapolitan-style pizza, made with a simple dough that’s allowed to slowly ferment, resulting in a light, airy crust with a characteristic char. The Pizzeria prides itself on using high-quality Italian ingredients, from the San Marzano tomatoes in their sauce to the creamy fior di latte mozzarella.
Their most popular pizza, the Margherita, is a testament to the beauty of simplicity. Topped with just tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil, it’s a pure expression of flavor. However, The Pizzeria also offers a range of more adventurous options, such as the Diavola, featuring spicy salami and chili flakes, and the Funghi, adorned with a medley of roasted mushrooms. What truly sets The Pizzeria apart is their commitment to authenticity. Their dough is made fresh daily, their ingredients are carefully sourced, and their pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven at scorching temperatures, resulting in a truly exceptional pie. The price range is moderate, making it a great spot for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner. You can find ample photos of the restaurant and its delicious pizzas on the Google Maps page. This is a true gem for anyone searching for great pizza St. John’s NL.
Coastal Crust: Where the Ocean Meets the Oven
Located just outside the city center, with breathtaking views of the coastline, Coastal Crust offers a pizza experience unlike any other. This family-run establishment has become a local favorite for its creative pizzas and its warm, welcoming atmosphere. Coastal Crust takes inspiration from both traditional Italian techniques and Newfoundland’s rich culinary heritage. They are known for their unique seafood pizzas, which showcase the bounty of the Atlantic.
The “Ocean’s Bounty” pizza is a must-try, featuring fresh shrimp, mussels, and scallops, all locally sourced, atop a creamy garlic sauce. Another popular option is the “Codfather,” a playful twist on a classic, with flaky cod, crispy fried onions, and a drizzle of Newfoundland dressing. Beyond their seafood pizzas, Coastal Crust also offers a range of more traditional options, all made with the same dedication to quality and flavor. They use fresh, local produce whenever possible, and their dough is made with a blend of whole wheat and white flour, resulting in a crust that is both flavorful and nutritious. What makes Coastal Crust truly special is its location. The stunning views of the coastline, combined with the delicious pizza and friendly service, create an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons often comment on the freshness of the ingredients and the inventive flavor combinations that set their pizza St. John’s NL apart from the rest. Prices are slightly higher than average, but the quality and the experience are well worth the splurge.
Slice of Life: A Budget-Friendly Favourite
For those seeking a delicious and affordable pizza option, Slice of Life is the perfect choice. This no-frills pizzeria, located near the university, is a popular spot for students and locals alike. Slice of Life offers a wide range of pizzas, from classic pepperoni to more creative combinations, all at incredibly reasonable prices.
Their signature pizza, the “Supreme,” is a crowd-pleaser, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, and onions. They also offer a variety of vegetarian options, including the “Veggie Deluxe,” featuring a medley of fresh vegetables. While Slice of Life may not have the same ambiance as some of the other pizzerias on this list, it makes up for it with its generous portions, tasty pizzas, and unbeatable prices. It’s the perfect place to grab a quick and satisfying meal without breaking the bank. The dough is made fresh daily, and the toppings are always plentiful. This is the go-to spot for pizza St. John’s NL if you’re looking for a great deal and a fast, tasty bite.
The Woodcutter’s Oven: Artisan Pizza in a Rustic Setting
Tucked away in a quieter part of town, The Woodcutter’s Oven offers a truly unique and artisan pizza experience. The restaurant’s interior is decorated in a rustic style, with exposed wooden beams, a crackling fireplace, and handmade furniture. The Woodcutter’s Oven is known for its creative and innovative pizzas, which feature locally sourced ingredients and unique flavor combinations.
Their “Wild Mushroom and Truffle” pizza is a must-try, featuring a medley of foraged mushrooms, truffle oil, and creamy goat cheese. They also offer a “Newfoundland Lobster” pizza, showcasing the region’s signature seafood atop a bed of garlic butter and herbs. Everything here is about high-quality ingredients and the careful crafting of the pizza. The wood-fired oven gives the pizzas a slight smoky char and a perfectly crisp crust. The Woodcutter’s Oven is a pricier option, but worth it for a special night out and a taste of the finer side of pizza St. John’s NL. This is where pizza becomes an art form.
More Than Just Pizza
While pizza is the star of the show at these establishments, most also offer a range of other menu items to complement your meal. Appetizers like garlic bread, bruschetta, and salads are common, and many pizzerias also serve pasta dishes, sandwiches, and desserts. Coastal Crust is known for its delicious fish and chips, a nod to Newfoundland’s maritime heritage. The Pizzeria offers a selection of Italian desserts, such as tiramisu and cannoli.
Nearly all mentioned restaurants offer delivery and takeout services, making it easy to enjoy their delicious pizzas from the comfort of your own home. And for those with dietary restrictions, several pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts, vegetarian options, and vegan cheese alternatives. Several of the restaurants mentioned also offer a great selection of local craft beers. A crisp Quidi Vidi iceberg beer perfectly complements a spicy pepperoni pizza, and a hoppy IPA pairs well with the richness of a seafood pie.
A Slice of Paradise: Your Pizza Journey Awaits
The pizza St. John’s NL scene is a testament to the city’s growing culinary sophistication and its passion for good food. Whether you’re craving a classic Neapolitan pie, a creative seafood creation, or a budget-friendly slice, St. John’s has something to satisfy every pizza lover. It’s a reflection of the city itself: vibrant, diverse, and full of surprises.
So, the next time you find yourself in St. John’s, be sure to embark on your own pizza adventure. Explore the various pizzerias, sample their unique offerings, and discover your own favorite slice of paradise. From the cozy neighbourhood pizzerias to the trendy downtown spots, the pizza in St. John’s is more than just a meal; it’s an experience, a taste of the city’s soul, and a reminder that even in the most remote corners of the world, the simple pleasure of a perfectly crafted pizza can bring people together.
